I wrote this in response to another post, let me hear your analysis....
Alien is the best of the four. The instigator of the whole series, high on suspense and tension, indeed a classic.
Aliens was meant to be a different breed of film all together, an action packed movie, and loved by many with the introduction of the queen.
Alien3 tried to go back to the roots of the alien films, the dark claustrophobic suspense of a killer creature stalking it's prey one by one. A very Gothic feel to it. Some say this was Sigourney Weavers best performance.
Alien Resurrection tried to be something it wasn't. It tried to be Aliens. Moderate action, cheesey characters and introduction of the new born, led this film to be held as the worst of the four.
Now we come to AVP. This little beast had us all foaming at the mouth, the hype was incredible, pred and alien fans alike waited with baited breath for the showdown of the century. What we got was nothing but a throw away movie. No name actors, passable script, plot holes gallour, great action but far too short. AVP left a bad taste in the mouth of fans, it was indeed, a let down.
www.thorndesigns.netdarkness of acheron