Stalker,
Human,
17 years ago
I personally really enjoyed AVP-R. I've been a hardcore fan of both franchises for nearly 13 years, & I honestly thought it was great. Sure it might have been a brainless 90-minute film with weak characters & script, but to be honest, after the first AVP, which was a complete cold-shoulder, Requiem was a breath of fresh air. The predators were brought back to form, which is definitely one of my strongest likes about the movie, although unfortunately most of the battles were one-sided.
As for the comments about the movie being dark, the Strauses actually explained that there were some "bad prints" recieved by some of the cinemas, which could explain some of that issue.
The film wasn't on the same level as Aliens or Predator...but did we really expect it to be? As it stands, on an entertainment scale at least, Requiem is head & shoulders above the last couple of films we've gotten, & considering the script that the Strauses had to work with, I think they did a fantastic job.